Saturday, 4 May 2013

Ethical consumers... isn't that oxymoronic?

1 Peter 3v3 says:

Your beauty should not come from outward adornment, such as elaborate hairstyles and the wearing of gold jewellery or fine clothes. Rather, it should be that of your inner self, the unfading beauty of a gentle and quiet spirit, which is of great worth in God’s sight. 

Powerful words, but this was not reflective in my large and expanding wardrobe! In the wise words of my mother: "all you need is one off, one on and one in the wash" and similarly:  “It’s only a bargain if you need it”. The reality is, that when it comes to clothes I can be a bit of a hoarder, I often justify buying clothes based on the fact that they are from charity shops and therefore, I am not only making my day a little bit better, but also making someone else's day better too. My love for 'charity shop finds' and my ‘anti-high street’ mentality has been something I have taken pride in. Though, this concept has been massively challenged since watching this video:

Crazy stuff ay! It's quite a lot to chew over. Of course, buying Fairtrade, wearing TOMS and finding charity shop bargains will always be first choice over less ethical options. NGOs address the problems globally we can easily separate ourselves from (e.g. starving orphans in Africa, sweatshop workers across Asia...). However, do they address the underlying problems within our own society? In some ways, no! 

As this video summarizes: 'You don't just buy a coffee in the consumerist act. You buy your redemption from being only a consumer'. It could therefore be argued that having ethical options exacerbates our consumerist and materialistic mentality. In fact, the argument could go as far as suggesting that the act of buying local or buying Fairtrade actually reduces the chances of people seeking alternative ways to give the voiceless a voice, to make poverty history and to engage in campaigns for universal fair trade, as by consuming more ethical products 'we have done our bit'. Though I hesitate to admit it, I can on some level relate to this.

 Paul wrote in Philippians 3v19-20: [people of the earth] "Their destiny is destruction, their god is their stomach, and their glory is in their shame. Their mind is set on earthly things. But our citizenship is in heaven. And we eagerly await a Savior from there, the Lord Jesus Christ"

As Matthew 6v21 sums up nicely: "For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also." Videos like this drive me crazy as they don't present a solution... rather, leave us feeling burdened and hopeless. However, here we see Jesus talking about consumerism and materialism in more applicational terms. We can live for something bigger and therefore loose the need to consume to keep up with earthly standards. The early church shared everything with one another in a community more set on serving than consuming. What a liberating truth! Jesus told us that we should not “love in word or speech but in deed and truth” (1John 3:18) and Jesus is a clear example for us on how to love your neighbor, and in particular, loving and helping the poor. 

So, keep buying fairtrade coffee, keep hunting out charity shop bargains and enjoy it! But be aware that firstly, the wider issue in our society is our reliance on 'stuff' and our need to 'consume' constantly. Secondly, there is a danger in feeling 'good' after giving to a charity though it reduces our personal interaction with the poor. Jesus was constantly on a relational level with the most needy in society and as a result, a revolution began. Shane Claiborne in his book 'the Irresistible revolution' (which I highly recommend) addresses this issue in more depth- lets cut out the middle man and get involved directly! Does 'Charity degrade and demoralise'? Well, that is a highly contested issue, but it's 'the least-worst' option available to us and has evolved first from our consumerist desires. So make sure your treasures are heavenly things, fix your eyes on Jesus, and continue to love the poor in every aspect of your life, whether in what you consume, the money you give, or the people you walk past in the street.


No comments:

Post a Comment